"Defend the Bible? I would as soon defend a lion." ~ C.H. SpurgeonIt's my own fault. There are some blogs out in the wider Christian blogosphere that I really should stop reading. They do more to make me cross, than to bless me. Some of my regular readers may want to skip this post while I get this off my chest...!
There is a widely used argument against modern-day prophecy that I have seen resurface over the last couple of days. It goes like this:
- The Scriptures are sufficient [ie. there is no more to come]
- The Scriptures are God's word
- If God were to speak today it would either:
- Constitute new scripture
- Carry less authority
Since it is heretical / absurd that either we should expect new Scripture to be written, or that the voice of God should be somehow diminished in authority, the only conclusion is that God no longer speaks.
By putting forward this argument I think they honestly believe that they are championing the sufficiency of scripture and the authority of God and his word, when in reality they undermine both!
Let's indulge in a little
reductio ad adsurdem, and assume for the moment that their logic is correct.
The logic does not just apply to prophecy, but to any direct or indirect communication from God. It's not just that prophecy
doesn't happen - it
cannot happen! Nor does it stop there, in order to preserve the sufficiency of his word, God is bound not only to not communicate through prophecy, but he is bound to keep silent for as long as his word is sufficient. Since the scriptures are not just sufficient, but
eternal, God, by inspiring the last line of Revelation, effectively struck himself dumb for all eternity!
So what will happen on the day of Judgement, when God comes in glory to judge the world? How will he say "Well done good an faithful servant"? How will he accuse the wicked of their sins?
Through mime?! With a game of charades?! Will we have to spend eternity with our fingers in our ears going "la la la", lest we accidentally overhear the voice of God, the sufficiency of Scripture is proved false, and thus God is proved a liar, and the whole of existence disappears in a puff of logic!
Consider also how ironic, that the great almighty living God, the one who rebuked the idolator, and mocked the idols for being mute, is now mute himself.
Absurd! Absurd! Absurd!So where is the argument flawed? Well, it is a well know logical fallacy known as
"Affirming the consequent". It goes like this: If A is true, then B. B is true therefore A must also be true. For example: "Cats climb trees. My brother climbs trees. Therefore my brother must be a cat!" In this case the fallacy is in assuming that because all Scripture is the word of God, every word of God must also be Scripture.
If it can be shown that God speaks outside of his sufficient self-revelation contained in the Scriptures then the whole argument collapses. This is easily demonstrated by reading what the sufficient Scriptures themselves say, rather than postulating supposition upon supposition based on notions of their sufficiency.
The heavens declare the glory of God, and the sky above proclaims his handiwork. (Ps 19:1)My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me. (Jn 10:27)Today, if you hear his voice, do not harden your hearts as in the rebellion. (Heb 3:15)Pursue love, and earnestly desire the spiritual gifts, especially that you may prophesy. (1Co 14:1)etc... etc... etc...Just how eternally sufficient are the Scriptures if they were out of date the moment they were complete? If as soon as the Scriptures were completed all the passages referring to the charismata no longer apply, that puts the eternal word of God on a par with the church phone-book. Hardly an endorsement for sufficiency!
No, here is what the sufficiency of the Scriptures means. In all the vast stretches of eternity that we spend with the Lord, hearing his voice directly [and that is why prophecies
will cease] we will never hear a single phrase, not a single word, that contradicts God's self-revelation contained in his word. There will never come a day when "all bets are off", and God redefines himself by another standard. What a mystery, what a miracle, that though we will spend all eternity hearing from the Lord and growing in our knowledge and appreciation of his infinite worth, we will never find anything that is not first laid out in the Scriptures themselves. This is why the Scriptures are always our ultimate test for any prophecy - God will never say anything, not now, not ever for all eternity, that contradicts his word.
If the sufficiency of Scripture can cope with an eternity of direct revelation from God, it can certainly cope with today's prophecy.God no more needs our efforts to protect the sufficiency of his word, than the ark needed Uzzah's outstretched hand!